Spirit In Action

Change IS coming. WE can make it GOOD.

Leave a comment

With White Supremacy on Display in Paris, a Celebration of Western Hypocrisy | Common Dreams

Skip to main content

With White Supremacy on Display in Paris, a Celebration of Western Hypocrisy

Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Common Dreams

With White Supremacy on Display in Paris, a Celebration of Western Hypocrisy


Ajamu Baraka

Though the western world clearly does not want to go there, an open discussion about recent violence in Paris, argues Baraka, “might have framed it as a classic blowback operation resulting from the weaponization of radical Whabbanism as a tool of Western power from the late 1970s to its current assignment in Syria.” (Photo: Romain Lefort/flickr/cc)

The “civilized” have created the wretched, quite coldly and deliberately, and do not intend to change the status quo; are responsible for their slaughter and enslavement; rain down bombs on defenseless children whenever and wherever they decide that their “vital interests” are menaced, and think nothing of torturing a man to death; these people are not to be taken seriously when they speak of the “sanctity” of human life, or the conscience of civilized world. —James Baldwin

I have witnessed the spectacle of Eurocentric arrogance many times over my long years of struggle and resistance to colonial/capitalist domination and dehumanization. The grotesque, 21st Century version of the “white man’s burden,” which asserts that the international community (meaning the West) has a moral and legal “responsibility to protect,” is one current example; the generalized acceptance by many in the West that their governments have a right to wage permanent war against the global “others” to maintain international order is another.

Yet, when I think I have seen it all, along comes the response to the attack at the racist, Islamophobic publication Charlie Hebdo. Even though I shouldn’t be surprised, I am still left in complete wonderment at the West’s unmitigated self-centeredness and self-righteous arrogance.

The millions who turned out on Sunday claimed to be marching in solidarity with the victims at Charlie Hebdo and against terrorism. They were joined by political leaders from across Europe, Israel and other parts of the world – on the same weekend reports were emerging that 2,000 Nigerians may have lost their lives at the hands of Boko Haram, another Muslim extremist group.

Surely there would be expressions of solidarity with the survivors in Nigeria at a gathering ostensibly to oppose terrorism and uphold the sanctity of life. But the expressions of solidarity never came. In fact, based on the attention the massacre received from the Western press, it was if the massacre had never happened.

It is clear that there was a different agenda for the march and a different set of concerns for Europe. The people of France mobilized themselves to defend what they saw as an attack against Western civilization. However, the events in Paris did not have to be framed as an existential attack on the imagined values of the liberal white West. Providing some context and making some political links may have been beneficial for attempting to understand what happened in the country and a political way forward beyond the appeal to racial jingoism.

The attack could have sparked an honest conversation about how many Muslims experience life in contemporary France and viewed French policies in various Muslim and Arab nations. It could have examined the relationship between the rise of radical Islam and the connection of that rise to the activities of various branches of the French intelligence services. An open discussion might have framed it as a classic blowback operation resulting from the weaponization of radical Whabbanism as a tool of Western power from the late 1970s to its current assignment in Syria. But those ideas were not allowed a forum on that massive stage.

Je Suis Charlie: European lives have always mattered more than others

The Je Suis Charlie slogan like one of those mindless advertising themes meant to appeal to the unconscious and the irrational, nevertheless, has to have cultural reference points, culturally embedded meanings that evoke the desire to want to buy a product, or in this case to identify with an imagined civilization. It does not matter that the supposed superiority of Western civilization and its values is based on constructed lies and myths, it is still the basis of a cross-class, transnational white identity. The white identity is so powerfully inculcated while simultaneously invisibalized that identification is not seen as the essentialized identity politics that people of color supposedly engage in, instead it is just being “human.” And as we witnessed this weekend and throughout the colonial world, identification with whiteness is not limited by one’s racial or national assignment.

It is not necessary in this short essay to even address the contradictory nature of the European self-understanding, how that self-perception is utterly disconnected from its practice, and how many people in the world see the 500-years European hegemony as an interminable nightmare.

However, for those folks who believe the simple assertion that black lives matter and that “racial progress” will be realized through progressive legislative reform derived from a better understanding of the harmful impact of racially discriminatory practices, the unfiltered expressions of white solidarity and the privileging of white life should be a wake-up call.

The humanity and cultures of Arabs and Muslims have been denigrated in France for decades. Full recognition of the humanity of Arabs and Muslims has always come at a cost – Arabs and Muslims are required to “assimilate,” to mimic French lifestyles, embrace the language, adopt the values and worldview of their cosmopolitan patrons. Older generations of fully colonized individuals subjected themselves to that degrading ritual, but later generations see this requirement as the colonial assault on their being that it is and have resisted.

It is the arrogant lack of respect for the ideas and culture of non-European peoples that drove the French ban on the wearing of the niqab and other traditional veiling clothing for Muslim women, just one example of the generalized discriminatory treatment of Arabs and Muslims in France. In this lager context, Charlie Hebdo’s blatant disregard and disrespect for another religion, shielded by an absolute commitment to freedom of speech that gives them blanket immunity, is now compounded by the “Je Suis Charlie campaign,” orchestrated in the name of upholding the values of liberal, Western civilization.

What it means for many of us in the Black community is that Je Suis Charlie has become a sound bite to justify the erasure of non-Europeans, and for ignoring the sentiments, values and views of the racialized “other.” In short, Je Suis Charlie has become an arrogant rallying cry for white supremacy that was echoed at the white power march on Sunday in Paris and in the popularity of the new issue of Charlie Hebdo.

A shared ethical framework under the system of capitalist/colonial white supremacy is impossible. Deeply grounded in the European psyche and in the contradictions of its “humanist” traditions, who was considered fully human always had qualifications, and equality was always a nuanced concept.

The contradictory ethical framework that informs the world view of Parisians is grounded in the colonial division of humanity that emerged out of the liberal humanist movement of the 18th Century. This tradition allowed for humanity to be divided into those people who were considered fully human with rights that should be respected and those peoples consigned to non-being. Those non-beings became eligible to have their lands taken, to be enslaved and murdered at will.

The valuation of white life over everyone else is a fundamental component of white supremacy and not limited to those people that might be defined as white. That is why no one cares about the families that weep for their love ones in Nigeria and no one marches for them. That is why anti-Muslim and anti-Arab violence has exploded across France but the only mention in the Western press is the supposed fear in the Jewish community. And that is why that after the attack in Baga, Nigerian authorities were largely silent until Nigerian President Goodluck finally issued a statement on terrorism where he forcefully condemned the attack in Paris!

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 License

Ajamu Baraka is a veteran activist and organizer. He is currently an associate fellow at theInstitute for Policy Studiesin Washington, DC and an editor and columnist for Black Agenda Report. Baraka was founding executive director of theUS Human Rights Network (USHRN) from July 2004 until June 201.1 He has also served on the boards of various national and international human rights organizations, including Amnesty International (USA) and the National Center for Human Rights Education. He is currently on the boards of the Center for Constitutional Rights;Africa Action; Latin American Caribbean Community Center; Diaspora Afrique; and theMississippi Workers’ Center for Human Rights.His website iswww.ajamubaraka.com

Share This Article

  • 26
  • 119
  • 1

Related Articles

On the Charlie Hebdo Massacre: Are the Worst Really Full of Passionate Intensity?

Days After Free Speech Rally, France Arrests 54 People for Offensive Speech

France Arrests a Comedian For His Facebook Comments, Showing the Sham of the West’s “Free Speech” Celebration

Senate Republicans Seize Upon Paris Attacks to Thwart Gitmo Closure

More in:
World, War & Peace,Rights

Charlie Hebdo, Race,European Union, War on Terror

Today’s Views

Andy Rowell

OPEC Wants to “Crush US Shale”…

Wenonah Hauter

The Research Is In: Regulations Alone Won’t Save Us From Climate Disaster

Ajamu Baraka

With White Supremacy on Display in Paris, a Celebration of Western Hypocrisy

Valerie Strauss

What Are These Civil Rights Groups Thinking?

Norman Solomon

Sterling Trial Opens in Security-State Matrix

Carl Takei

How US Prison Officials Rubberstamped a CIA Torture Chamber

Glenn Greenwald

France Arrests a Comedian For His Facebook Comments, Showing the Sham of the West’s “Free Speech” Celebration

Mary Bottari

Democrats Gear Up to Battle Wall Street in the New Congress

Jim Hightower

Cannabis Americas Common Sense Crops

Slavoj Žižek

On the Charlie Hebdo Massacre: Are the Worst Really Full of Passionate Intensity?

Rory Fanning

Letter to a Young Army Ranger (From an Old One): ‘Why the War on Terror Shouldn’t Be Your Battle’…

Cynthia Wong

Reclaiming Privacy in the Golden Age of Surveillance

More Views

News That Matters

Not One, But Eight Reports Show Big Money Dominates Post-Citizens United Landscape
Days After Free Speech Rally, France Arrests 54 People for Offensive Speech
Offshore Wind Blows Drilling Out of the Water: Report
How Regressive Local Taxes Are Rewarding the Rich
With Wall Street Holding the Strings, Republican-Controlled Congress Moves to Deregulate Big Banks
White House: ‘We Look Forward’ to Working with GOP on Limitless War
Social Cost of Climate Change Vastly Underestimated
Senate Republicans Seize Upon Paris Attacks to Thwart Gitmo Closure
China Goes ‘Rogue’ With ‘Artificial Weather’ Scheme
Island States Throw Off the Heavy Yoke of Fossil Fuels


Saudi Perfidy: Ten Years and 1,000 Lashes For Seeking to “Respect the Differences Among Us”

The same day a Saudi official marched in Paris for free speech, his country – the one that persecutes/jails writers/activists and considers women drivers terrorists – dragged jailed blogger Raif Badawi into the public square and flogged him 50 times for “insulting Islam,” the first of 20 scheduled floggings. Tuesday he marked his 31st birthday. Friday, despite global outrage, he will likely be lashed again. From one of his last posts: “Let us all live under the roof of human civilization.”

Read More…

More Further

Connect With Us

About Common Dreams

Our Mission:
To inform. To inspire.
To ignite change for the common good.

Common Dreams has been providing breaking news & views for the progressive community since 1997. We are independent, non-profit, advertising-free and 100% reader supported.


Leave a comment

The four major stages of reality-shaping consciousness–where’s your tent pitched?

Thank you Pam! I love the way you are able to simplify big ideas into things anyone can easily understand and do.
This is for everyone who would like a straightforward road map to “raising your vibration”, “manifesting” or basically just having a lot more fun and less stress in your life;-)

Pam Grout

“Being spiritual has nothing to do with what you believe and everything to do with your state of consciousness.”
― Eckhart Tolle

Our consciousness shapes and molds the reality that plays out in our lives. And there are many levels of consciousness, each with different rules, principles, characteristics and attributes.

For example, if you reside in the victim consciousness (“Things happen TO me,” “Life sucks and then you die” are a few standard thoughts from this level.), you can affirm and intend all you want, but your consciousness, the driver of your reality, which believes affirmations and intentions are a bunch of hooey always gets the last word. When you spend most of your waking hours in that consciousness (and it’s a very popular consciousness), your channels are plugged up. All the good that wants to come your way can’t get through.

Because we live in a multi-dimensional universe, there…

View original post 711 more words

Leave a comment

Truthout Daily Digest | Tuesday, 13 January 2015

Dahr Jamail | The Methane Monster Roars

Dahr Jamail, Truthout: Losing Arctic sea ice due to rising global temperatures means releasing larger amounts of previously trapped methane into the atmosphere. This process will magnify the effects of climate disruption, which, scientists warn, threaten all plants, animals and humans on earth.

Read the Article

As Frac Sand Mining Expands, Community Activists Face Off Against Companies

Mara Kardas-Nelson, Truthout: With lax US and state government oversight of frac sand mining, a little-known industry producing a key component of fracking, it is up to cities and towns in Wisconsin to fight off powerful mining interests, and the state of Iowa is taking note.

Read the Article

Do Prisons and Mass Incarceration Keep Us Safe? (Part Two)

Eddie Conway, The Real News Network: Truthout’s Maya Schenwar, author of Locked Down, Locked Out, continues her discussion, this time focusing on alternatives to mass incarceration.

Watch the Video and Read the Transcript

Are Assad’s Days Numbered?

Darius Shahtahmasebi, Truthout: As the US-led coalition continues to bomb ISIS and support rebels fighting the Syrian government, it’s only logical that Bashar al-Assad will eventually become the target of the US campaign.

Read the Article

Ethiopia, Seen by West as an Island of Stability, Is Guilty of State Terrorism in Ogaden

Graham Peebles, Truthout: A shining example of African economic growth, a willing ally in the “war on terror” and a strategically convenient base from which the United States launches deadly Reaper drones over Yemen and Somalia, Ethiopia is also an egregious violator of human rights.

Read the Article

Putting $7 Trillion of Notional Value of Derivatives in Taxpayer-Backstopped Depositaries Will Cost Zero

Yves Smith, Naked Capitalism: Why did Elizabeth Warren lose her battle to stop banks from parking $7 trillion notional value of risky derivatives like the credit defaults swaps in taxpayer-backstopped depositaries? One of the less recognized reasons is that the Congressional Budget Office’s dubious analysis said it would not cost taxpayers a dime.

Read the Article

Four Ways the West Got the Iran Nuclear Issue Wrong

Gareth Porter, Middle East Eye: For decades, the United States and its European allies have committed one error after another in the process of creating a commonly held narrative that Iran was secretly pursuing a nuclear weapons program. The story of how suspicions of the Iranian program hardened into convictions is a cautionary tale.

Read the Article

How Cuba Is Using Cooperatives to Decentralize Its Economy

Cat Johnson, Care2: With the recent announcement that the United States will normalize relations with Cuba, change is in the air for the island country. Just a few years ago, Cuba began shifting its economy from state-controlled enterprises to citizen-controlled cooperatives. Will this trend continue?

Read the Article

Surprising New Findings Point to “Perfect Storm” Brewing in Your Financial Future

Lynn Stuart Parramore, Institute for New Economic Thinking: Groundbreaking research by economist Alan Taylor shows that today‘s advanced economies depend on private sector credit more than ever before. Do we just fasten our seat belts for a bumpy ride, or is there a way to safeguard the financial system going forward?

Read the Interview

Seven Ways to Get Happy – Without Costing the Planet

Sarah van Gelder, YES! Magazine: It is true that all of us need a basic level of material security. But after that, more stuff does not bring more happiness. Research shows that sustainable happiness comes from other sources, like having meaningful work to do and having authentic relationships.

Read the Article

Letter to a Young Army Ranger: Why the War on Terror Shouldn’t Be Your Battle

Rory Fanning, TomDispatch: “If, by any chance, you haven’t signed that Option 40 contract yet, you don’t have to. You can be an effective counter-recruiter without being an ex-military guy. Young people across this country desperately need your energy, your desire to be the best, your pursuit of meaning.”

Read the Article

On the News With Thom Hartmann: Last Year Was the Hottest Year on Record, and More

In today‘s On the News segment: According to the Japan Meteorological Agency, 2014 was hotter than any other year in its 120 years of record-keeping; California has big plans for reducing its carbon footprint; scientists have discovered the most Earth-like planet ever found outside of our solar system; and more.

Watch the Video and Read the Transcript


Chaplain Employed by For-Profit Prison Accused of Whitewashing Immigrant Detention Abuses

Mark Karlin, BuzzFlash at Truthout: As with the prison system in general, for-profit corporations that run immigrant jails are interested in filling the maximum number of beds in order to achieve increased profit.

Read the BuzzFlash Commentary

Social Justice Quiz 2015: How Much Do You Know About Inequality?

Read the Article at BuzzFlash

Paris Rally for Peace: Massive Crowd Sings “Imagine” by John Lennon

Watch the Video on YouTube

The Legacy of Bill Moyers

Read the Article at The Washington Post

Elizabeth Warren Wins: Obama Treasury Pick Bows Out of Nomination Process

Read the Article at Talking Points Memo

The Group Behind the United States’ Biggest Anti-Abortion March Now Says Birth Control Causes Abortions

Read the Article at Mother Jones

Protecting Your Mentally Ill Child From the Cops

Read the Article at The Daily Beast

South African Labor Leader Pitches a New Socialist Party

Read the Article at Al Jazeera America